elden ring dlc should i start a new character

3 min read 15-04-2025

elden ring dlc should i start a new character

Meta Description: Embarking on the Elden Ring DLC? This guide tackles the burning question: new character or continue your existing journey? We weigh the pros and cons, helping you decide the optimal approach for maximum enjoyment of the Shadow of the Erdtree expansion. Discover the best strategies for tackling the challenging new content and maximizing your experience in the Lands Between!

Introduction: Embracing the Shadow of the Erdtree

The release of Elden Ring's highly anticipated DLC, Shadow of the Erdtree, presents a tantalizing dilemma for players: should you forge a fresh character or continue your existing epic journey through the Lands Between? This decision hinges on various factors, from your playstyle and build to your desire for a completely fresh experience versus maximizing existing progress. This comprehensive guide breaks down the pros and cons of each approach, helping you make the informed choice that best suits your needs. We'll explore the optimal path for enjoying the new content. Let's delve into the depths of this decision.

Starting a New Character: A Fresh Perspective

Pros of Starting Fresh

Clean Slate: Beginning anew grants a clean slate. Experiment with a different build, class, or playstyle without the constraints of your previous choices. Try a faith-based build, or maybe a pure strength warrior if you usually play a mage.
Undisturbed Exploration: A new character allows for unadulterated exploration of the DLC's new areas without the distraction of remembering previous runs. This helps you immerse yourself completely.
Unburdened Inventory: Starting over means a fresh inventory. You won't be bogged down by carrying excessive items from your previous playthrough.
New Challenges: Relearning the mechanics with a new character can be incredibly rewarding, especially for experienced players. It might introduce new challenges and a renewed sense of exploration.
Optimal Leveling: New characters offer the chance to level up in a way that optimizes your character for the DLC's unique challenges and enemy types.

Cons of Starting Fresh

Time Commitment: Creating and leveling a new character requires significant time investment. This is especially true if you aim to reach a high level before tackling the DLC.
Lost Progress: You'll lose all progress made on your previous character, including equipment, runes, and discovered areas within the base game.
Potential Regret: You might regret starting over if you realize later that your new build isn't working as well as expected. This can be frustrating.

Continuing Your Existing Character: Building Upon Success

Pros of Continuing Your Existing Character

Preserved Progress: Your existing character retains all acquired equipment, runes, and knowledge gained during the main game. You can immediately dive into the DLC.
Time Savings: Continuing your existing character saves considerable time compared to leveling a new character from scratch.
Familiar Build: You already know your build's strengths and weaknesses. This is crucial when facing new challenges.
Story Continuity: Continuing your character maintains story continuity and immersion, enhancing the narrative experience of the DLC.

Cons of Continuing Your Existing Character

Build Limitations: Your current build might not be ideal for the DLC's challenges. You might encounter significant difficulty if you are not optimally equipped.
Inventory Management: Carrying over a massive inventory from the base game can be cumbersome. Consider streamlining your items before delving into the new content.
Reduced Exploration: Your prior knowledge of the game might impact your level of exploration in the DLC areas.

Which Approach Suits You Best? A Decision Matrix

The best approach truly depends on your personal preferences. Consider the following:

Experienced Player: If you've completed multiple playthroughs, starting a new character allows for experimentation with new builds and a refreshing experience.
Casual Player: If you're a casual player, continuing your existing character saves time and allows you to experience the DLC without starting over.
Build Optimization: If optimizing your character for the DLC is your priority, you might choose either to make a completely new character or to respec your current build.
Narrative Immersion: If narrative immersion is key, continue your existing journey to maintain continuity.

Conclusion: Embrace the Shadows

Ultimately, the decision of whether to start a new character or continue your existing one for the Elden Ring DLC is a personal one. Carefully consider the pros and cons outlined above, weigh your priorities, and choose the path that best aligns with your personal gaming style. No matter your choice, the Shadow of the Erdtree promises a thrilling expansion to the already immense world of Elden Ring. May your journey through the Lands Between be filled with adventure and triumph!